View Full Version: Murder inside Fort Bonifacio?

Philippines Defense Forces Forum > Philippine Army > Murder inside Fort Bonifacio?


Title: Murder inside Fort Bonifacio?
Description: Army officer found dead inside barracks


Iron Dragon - April 24, 2008 07:12 AM (GMT)
MANILA -- Colonel Roberto Caldeo, a staff officer at the Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP) Command and General Staff College, was found lifeless inside his Fort Bonifacio quarters Thursday morning.

A neighbor discovered the body at about 8:30 a.m. after hearing a gunshot inside the quarters.

The scene-of-the-crime investigators (Soco) are already looking into the case. The Armed Forces will also conduct a separate investigation.

Caldeo graduated from the Philippine Military Academy (PMA) in 1983 and he received the distinguished conduct star, the second to the highest military award, and several other combat awards.

He was also commander of the First Scout Ranger Battalion and the 33rd Infantry Battalion, both in Mindanao.

The cause of his death is yet to be known.

http://www.sunstar.com.ph/static/net/2008/...2.20.p.m.).html

what a waste...RIP :salute:

valiant - April 24, 2008 10:04 AM (GMT)
suicide yan

didu - April 24, 2008 11:13 AM (GMT)
di ba there was also an air force colonel who died of similar circumstances early this month?

:armyeek:

mazingu - April 24, 2008 02:52 PM (GMT)
sir, your topic title is very sensational, like that of a tabloid headline.

the cause of death is very likely suicide because theres a suicide letter in the scene

Fmr TOPP Awardee 82'PNP - April 24, 2008 10:09 PM (GMT)
The topic starter may have sensationalized it, but as we can see, it was punctuated by a question mark at the end of the phrase which denotes uncertainty before anything official comes up to prove whether it's murder or suicide.

And if it was a suicide case, it still answers the same question that it was not murder.

Murder & suicide are both sensational. So, it makes no difference at all.

Tora^2 - April 25, 2008 11:35 AM (GMT)
Reminds of an incident years back where a young Navy Ensign who died under similar circumstances in his cabin in the vessel he was stationed in. He was found to have shot allegedly shot himself.

The Ensign's name was Philippe Pestano.
http://pinoyworld.wordpress.com/2007/11/22/cargo/

I won't be surprised if the suicide angle seems smelly


Fmr TOPP Awardee 82'PNP - April 26, 2008 01:26 AM (GMT)
We are just hoping that the investigation will not encounter some barriers of cover-up and fraternal code of silence so that all facts of the case to ferret out the truth will come out.

MAY THE OFFICER REST IN PEACE.

nightstalker - April 26, 2008 05:22 AM (GMT)
MANILA, Philippines -- The colonel found dead in his Fort Bonifacio quarters Thursday was the third soldier who took part in a fierce 2000 battle against Abu Sayyaf extremists in Basilan to die in an alleged suicide, his fellow Scout Rangers said.

Aside from Colonel Roberto Caldeo, a sergeant and a lieutenant of the elite unit allegedly also took their own lives years after the three-day assault on Puno (Mt.) Mohaji in Isabela City in late April 2000, according to a Scout Ranger junior officer who was part of the operation.

Caldeo commanded the 1st Scout Ranger Battalion, which was tasked to assault Puno Mohaji to rescue dozens of teachers, students, and a Catholic priest held hostage by the Abu Sayyaf.

Another junior officer in the Rangers who was stationed in Basilan at the time, said the three soldiers could have been driven to suicide because of depression over the assault, in which six soldiers were killed and 50 wounded. More than 20 Abu Sayyaf fighters were also killed.

"Wala talagang stress management sa Army [There really is no stress management in the Army]," the second source said.

The junior officers spoke on condition of anonymity because they are not authorized to speak to media.

Caldeo was found dead with a gunshot wound to his forehead on Thursday morning.

Army spokesman Lieutenant Colonel Ernesto Torres Jr. said a note and a handgun found on the scene could indicate suicide, although he stressed that the police investigation into the incident is continuing.

A classmate of Caldeo’s at the Philippine Military Academy (PMA) confirmed his late “mistah” was bothered by the Puno Mohaji incident up until the time of his death.

"I believe so, that [Puno Mohaji] is one of the things he shared with us. A number of soldiers died under his watch," Colonel Daniel Lucero, president of PMA Class 1983 to which Caldeo belonged, said.

Asked if Caldeo may have felt guilty because of the casualties, Lucero said: "Not actually guilt. It's care for the affected families [of the casualties]."

"Leading men to battle could mean losing lives," said Lucero, a former military spokesman who is the current head executive assistant to the Armed Forces Chief of Staff.

Another classmate, Colonel Ricardo Visaya, said Caldeo was "very secretive" especially when it came to personal problems.

Torres said the Army does have a team of medical experts who conduct stress management but conceded that: "We can't say that 100 percent [of troops] undergo the procedure."

He explained that those who figure in major encounters are prioritized for stress debriefing but could not immediately confirm if the soldiers involved in the Puno Mohaji operation underwent this.

Torres said ground commanders are expected to be "creative" and conduct stress management on their men. Troops who have not gone home for some time or those with family problems are allowed to go on vacation.

"We have professional medical experts [but] hindi natin laging kasama sila [they are not always with us]," he said.

The first Ranger officer joked that soldiers go to watering holes for stress debriefing.

The Puno Mohaji raid earned for Caldeo the Distinguished Conduct Star, the second highest combat medal in the military, but the honor came three years after the encounter.

It also earned for a young officer, then Second Lieutenant Herbert Dilag, the military's highest honor, the Medal of Valor. Dilag led a 14-man team on a "suicide mission" that finally overran the bandit camp.

But Caldeo was relieved as brigade commander after the hostages were rescued from Puno Mohaji and was reassigned to the 33rd Infantry Battalion in Sulu province.

The first source claimed Caldeo earned the ire of superiors, one of whom threatened to remove the “tabak” or native sword on the Scout Ranger emblem, as his troops suffered casualties during the Puno Mohaji assault.

"Instead of [getting] praise, we got criticized," he said.
http://newsinfo.inquirer.net/breakingnews/...lash-in-suicide

RIP

zundino - April 27, 2008 08:04 AM (GMT)
no murder but suicide, col. caldeo was suffering from the effects of the bloody battles in his past while he was still co of the 1fsrr. he finally found the peace he was looking for.

the system could be partly blamed for failing to provide support to battle-scarred soldiers and officers who are most guilt-ridden for the deaths of eps under their commands




Fmr TOPP Awardee 82'PNP - April 27, 2008 09:54 AM (GMT)
What a miserable death if suicide was the culprit. Has there been already an official finding to that effect Zundino ?

What a pity and waste for a promising army officer to die that way and early. It might be that his normal psychological-being snapped out and ended up cutting off his own life. There is a greater part of blame to be addressed to the AFP for not providing counselling and rehabilitation of officers and men feeling or suffering the psychological or ill-effects from the combat zone.

The deceased officer might have suffered horrible flashbacks of the encounter he came across thus affecting his psychological well-being. If he was being looked after by the AFP the earlier time, chances are he is still with us at this precise moment.

Numbers - April 28, 2008 06:40 AM (GMT)
May the colonel's soul rest in peace.

PTSD has been attributed to be the major culprit in the epidemic of suicides among US Iraq War veterans, and this from a country with advanced psychological/psychiatric support for its servicemembers.

Compare this with the AFP's own minimal/absent psychiatric care and you would understand why the system failed officers like Col. Caldeo.


valiant - April 28, 2008 06:59 AM (GMT)
very interesting insight sir nmbers and it looks like you're right on the money. There were 2 other prior suicides from the same group of Rangers involved in the Basilan encounter which could have raised a warning flag on Col. Caldeo's situation.

http://newsinfo.inquirer.net/breakingnews/...lash-in-suicide

Comrades: Caldeo 3rd vet of 2000 Basilan clash in ‘suicide’

By Joel Guinto
INQUIRER.net
First Posted 17:47:00 04/25/2008


MANILA, Philippines -- The colonel found dead in his Fort Bonifacio quarters Thursday was the third soldier who took part in a fierce 2000 battle against Abu Sayyaf extremists in Basilan to die in an alleged suicide, his fellow Scout Rangers said.

Aside from Colonel Roberto Caldeo, a sergeant and a lieutenant of the elite unit allegedly also took their own lives years after the three-day assault on Puno (Mt.) Mohaji in Isabela City in late April 2000, according to a Scout Ranger junior officer who was part of the operation.

Caldeo commanded the 1st Scout Ranger Battalion, which was tasked to assault Puno Mohaji to rescue dozens of teachers, students, and a Catholic priest held hostage by the Abu Sayyaf.

Another junior officer in the Rangers who was stationed in Basilan at the time, said the three soldiers could have been driven to suicide because of depression over the assault, in which six soldiers were killed and 50 wounded. More than 20 Abu Sayyaf fighters were also killed.

"Wala talagang stress management sa Army [There really is no stress management in the Army]," the second source said.

The junior officers spoke on condition of anonymity because they are not authorized to speak to media.

Caldeo was found dead with a gunshot wound to his forehead on Thursday morning.

Army spokesman Lieutenant Colonel Ernesto Torres Jr. said a note and a handgun found on the scene could indicate suicide, although he stressed that the police investigation into the incident is continuing.

A classmate of Caldeo’s at the Philippine Military Academy (PMA) confirmed his late “mistah” was bothered by the Puno Mohaji incident up until the time of his death.

"I believe so, that [Puno Mohaji] is one of the things he shared with us. A number of soldiers died under his watch," Colonel Daniel Lucero, president of PMA Class 1983 to which Caldeo belonged, said.

Asked if Caldeo may have felt guilty because of the casualties, Lucero said: "Not actually guilt. It's care for the affected families [of the casualties]."

"Leading men to battle could mean losing lives," said Lucero, a former military spokesman who is the current head executive assistant to the Armed Forces Chief of Staff.

Kampilan - May 9, 2008 10:00 AM (GMT)
QUOTE (Numbers @ Apr 28 2008, 02:40 PM)
May the colonel's soul rest in peace.

PTSD has been attributed to be the major culprit in the epidemic of suicides among US Iraq War veterans, and this from a country with advanced psychological/psychiatric support for its servicemembers.

Compare this with the AFP's own minimal/absent psychiatric care and you would understand why the system failed officers like Col. Caldeo.

The US has set up a special suicide hotline for Afghanistan and Iraq war veterans 20% of whom suffer from symptoms of PTSD and depression. The AFP can establish a similar system for its war veterans and active duty soldiers.





Hosted for free by InvisionFree